Shopify vs Etsy for New Business Owners
Starting a business? You’ve probably hit the question that keeps popping up in every entrepreneur forum: Etsy vs Shopify. Do you set up your own Shopify shop and store on Shopify, or join the Etsy platform with its massive marketplace? The truth is, both platforms work, but in very different ways. Choosing the right one can save you from wasted fees per sale, growth plateaus, and brand headaches later.
At Sleepless Media, we’ve worked with everyone from small businesses and beginners to fast-scaling ecommerce brands. Here’s a clear, expert breakdown of Etsy vs Shopify to help you make the smart choice.
Shopify vs Etsy: The Core Difference
Shopify is a platform where you run your own branded store, design the site using a template, connect Shopify payments, and manage an unlimited number of products.
Whereas Etsy is a marketplace with built-in shoppers, but heavy competition and less control.
Think of Shopify as owning a home. You design it, decorate it, and expand it as you please. Whereas Etsy is like renting a booth at a giant craft fair. People are walking by, but the fair organizers control the rules, layout, and listing fee structure.
Thinking of moving beyond Etsy? Let Sleepless Media build you a Shopify store that’s ready to scale.
1. Platform Type: Ownership vs Marketplace
Shopify is a standalone e-commerce platform where you can sell online, integrate Shopify apps, and fully run your business.
Etsy allows sellers to join a shared ecosystem. You can be discovered quickly, but you are also at the mercy of Etsy’s policies, Etsy search algorithm, and Etsy payment system.
If you want independence and to scale your business, Shopify is great. If you just want to test if your products sell, use Etsy as the easier on-ramp.
2. Product Focus: What Sells Where
An Etsy shop is best for those who sell handmade, vintage items, and craft supplies. Buyers trust Etsy for unique goods, and Etsy sales continue to thrive in those niches.
Shopify doesn’t limit you. You can sell anything legal: clothing, digital products, print-on-demand, furniture, or even bookings. Shopify helps with multichannel selling, too, so you can sync with marketplaces like Amazon.
If your products fit Etsy’s niche, start there. But Shopify offers freedom to diversify your business, selling products of all kinds.
3. Audience and Traffic: Borrow vs Build
Etsy offers built-in traffic. Millions of buyers and sellers interact daily, so you don’t have to fight for initial exposure. The catch? You’re competing inside the Etsy pattern ecosystem, and you don’t control how much traffic to your shop Etsy decides to send.
Shopify doesn’t provide traffic. You need SEO, ads, and marketing. But every customer you win stays with you. Shopify even gives you tools like Shopify email and selling tools to keep building repeat customers.
Pro tip: For quick wins, sell on Etsy. For long-term growth, use Shopify.
4. Branding Control: Building a Name That Sticks
On Shopify, your brand shines. From your Shopify shop design to email flows, Shopify provides sellers with tools to stand out. Customers remember your brand, not the platform.
On Etsy, customers often remember Etsy. Shops look similar, and Etsy pushes its own brand above yours.
If your business needs brand recognition, Shopify allows complete control.
5. Ease of Setup: Fast Start vs Custom Build
Etsy shops are quick to set up. You can open an Etsy store, upload photos, and list your products in a day. That’s why many beginners start here.
Shopify takes more effort. You’ll choose a template, integrate Shopify apps, and set up Shopify payments. But the result looks more professional and is better for running a business long-term.
If you want fast exposure, use Etsy. If you want to scale your business, Shopify is a platform where you can build for the future.
6. Cost Structure: Fees vs Predictable Pricing
On Etsy, you’ll need to pay a listing fee, plus transaction and payment fees. That adds up, especially if you sell more or use Etsy Plus.
Shopify has a predictable cost. A Shopify plan starts at $39. You don’t pay per listing, and you can add an unlimited number of products.
Etsy looks cheaper upfront, but Shopify might save more as your sales grow.
7. Customer Data: The Secret to Growth
Shopify gives you customer insights. You can build lists, retarget, and automate with Shopify apps. This is how brands scale your business.
Etsy keeps most data. Unlike Etsy, Shopify gives you the tools to make it easy to grow loyalty and repeat sales.
8. Scalability: From Side Hustle to Empire
Whereas Etsy is a marketplace best for hobbyists, Shopify can grow with you. From small shops to enterprises with a Shopify partner, the tools are there. You can add a number of products, use multichannel selling, and even run print-on-demand stores.
Powered by Shopify, big brands can handle thousands of orders without switching platforms.
If you want to grow, sell on Shopify early.
Brands that migrate from Etsy to Shopify see 2–3x higher repeat purchase rates within the first year.
Which Businesses Benefit Most from Shopify vs Etsy
-
Best for Etsy: Hobbyists, artists who sell handmade, vintage sellers, and those who just want to test.
-
Best for Shopify: Ambitious brands, businesses selling products at scale, and entrepreneurs who want independence.
At Sleepless Media, we’ve seen many Etsy and Shopify sellers. But long-term winners almost always use Shopify to control growth.
FAQs
Can I sell on both Shopify and Etsy?
Yes. Many sellers run both. Etsy is useful for exposure, while sell on shopify for brand building.
Is Shopify harder to learn than Etsy?
Slightly, but shopify provides guides, customer support, and partners. With a shopify partner or agency, setup is faster.
Which is cheaper, Shopify or Etsy?
If you only sell on Etsy occasionally, it may cost less. But once sales grow, a shopify plan is more cost-effective.
Can I migrate from Etsy to Shopify?
Yes. You can move from an etsy store to a store on Shopify using migration apps.
Which is better for SEO: Shopify or Etsy?
Shopify wins. You can optimize blogs, product pages, and run your business for long-term growth.
Etsy Gave You a Start. Shopify Gives You the Future
Etsy is great for early visibility. But if you want to scale your business, own your data, and keep profits, Shopify is the long-term move.
Sleepless Media has helped countless sellers move from Etsy shops to full Shopify stores. If you’re ready to stop renting customers and start building, Shopify helps you get there.
Ready to run your business smarter? Sleepless Media can build you a Shopify shop that grows with you.
